Recent Posts in child endangerment Category
| April 03, 2012 |
| Is it legal to spank a child in Virginia? |
| Posted By Shawn Cline |
 |
I often meet with well meaning parents who have been accused of assault on a family member in violation of Virginia Code §18.2-57.2 who are in fact guilty of nothing more than spanking an unruly child. These concerned parents want to know whether spanking is a crime in Virginia. The answer is more complicated than one might suspect. First and foremost, spanking a child is not prohibited in Virginia, and there is no Virginia Code section directly on point in this regard. However, the Virginia Supreme Court has provided some guidance on the matter in stating that "a parent has a right to punish a child within the bounds of moderation and reason, so long as he does it for the welfare of the child; but if he exceeds due moderation, he becomes criminally liable."
Carpenter v. Commonwealth, 186 Va. 851 (1947). The problem with this rule is that "moderation and reason" lack any specific definition. Is it acceptable to spank a child twice? How about ten times? What if I use a belt? Or a switch? None of these questions are answered directly. However, the Court provides some guidance in that the legality of a particular manner and degree of corporal punishment shall be determined by taking into consideration the "age, size and conduct of the child, the nature of his misconduct, the nature of the instrument used for punishment, and the kind of marks or wounds inflicted on the body of the child".
The bottom line is that in Virginia, parents (and those acting in parental roles) may spank or otherwise corporally discipline a child as long as they do so within the bounds of "moderation and reason". Unfortunately, parents using this method of behavior modification do so at their own risk. Our society is increasingly intolerant of discipline in any form and increasingly tolerant of bad behavior in children. What you may view as punishment of a child within the bounds of moderation and reason may be viewed by a judge or jury as a criminal assault. If you or someone you love are facing a charge related to spanking or disciplining a child, contact us right away. We understand this complex area of law and are ready to fight for you!
|
|
| Continue reading "Is it legal to spank a child in Virginia?" » |
|
Permalink  |
| |
| July 12, 2011 |
| What are Virginia child abuse laws? |
| Posted By Shawn Cline |
|
I frequently meet with distraught parents who have been charged with child neglect or abuse. In most cases, these are loving parents who either lacked the skills and resources to effectively care for their children; or in many cases these are parents being accused of something they simply did not do. These parents and guardians are confused and scared, so it is important first and foremost to have an understanding of the Virginia Code as it relates to child abuse and neglect. The good news is that I am going to go over much of it in this article. The bad news is that it is still terribly complex (as you will no doubt see). The bottom line is that if you are facing any charge in Virginia relating to abuse or neglect of a child, you need to contact us right away. That being said, here is the rundown:
The Commonwealth's Attorney always has the liberty to charge crimes against children under the general statutes; be it Murder in any degree, assault and battery,
malicious wounding, or any of a myriad of
sexual abuse charges. These types of charges are discussed elsewhere on this website, so I will not go into them further here. Instead, I want to focus on the types of charges that are specifically directed at abuse and neglect of children.
The most serious child abuse charge is under Virginia Code Section 18.2-371.1, Abuse and Neglect of Children. Within this code section are two different offenses, the more serious is a class 4 felony, carrying up to 10 years in the penitentiary. The lesser offense is a class 6 felony, carrying up to 5 years in the penitentiary. Both offenses require that the accused be the "parent, guardian, or other person responsible for the care of a child under the age of 18". So you can see one possible defense right there, if you do not fit that definition under the law, you cannot be convicted of either offense (although you may still be guilty of another offense, such as assault and battery). The code requires that the accused "willful act or omission or refusal to provide any necessary care... causes serious injury to the life or health of such child" to be guilty of the class 4 felony. The code defines "serious injury" as including, but not limited to "(1) disfigurement, (2) a fracture, (3) a severe burn or laceration, (4) mutilation, (5) maiming, (6) forced ingestion of dangerous substances, (7) life-threatening internal injuries." Unless the accused's act or failure to act directly causes one of these conditions or a comparable condition, they cannot be convicted of the class 4 felony.
That being said, the code allows for a lesser offense within the same statute for a class 6 felony. The code provides that any parent, guardian, etc. whose "willful act or omission in the care of such child was so gross, wanton, and culpable as to show a reckless disregard for human life shall be guilty of a class 6 felony". As you can see, there is no actual injury required under this part of the code. As long as the responsible adult's conduct showed reckless disregard for the child's life, they can be convicted of this less severe (but still very serious) charge.
As you can see, there are two theories for conviction for both of these felony charges. One is a specific act, the other is a failure to act. In other words, it is not always a defense to say "I didn't do anything". The idea is that a responsible adult has an obligation to act under certain circumstances. Doing nothing is sometimes not acceptable. A good way of looking at this would be to think of a firearm in the home. A responsible parent ought to secure firearms in the home, particularly where the children are of an age where they may be curious but not yet capable of understanding the consequences of using a firearm. For this reason, a parent might be charged under one of these statutes for failure to secure a firearm if the result of such failure was the death of a third party at the hands of an armed child. This is just an example, and should not be considered as controlling or limiting in any way.
Cases involving neglect and abuse of children are not always felonies. In fact, in most child abuse and neglect cases emerge as misdemeanors. Code Section 18.2-371 is the basic Contributing to the Delinquency of a Minor statute in Virginia. This statute makes it a class 1 misdemeanor, punishable by up to 12 months in jail, for any person over 18 years of age who "willfully contributes to, encourages, or causes any act, omission, or condition which renders a child delinquent, in need of services, in need of supervision, or abused or neglected". This is still a serious offense, but far less serious than the felonies discussed previously. These cases typically involve a lack of supervision, or perhaps even active facilitation, on the part of an adult which causes a child to engage in illegal or dangerous conduct. These cases often involve allowing minors access to drugs or alcohol.
There is a final way in which these types of charges can be brought in Virginia, although it is rarely used. Within the Child Labor section of the code is Section 40.1-103, which prohibits any "person employing or having custody" of a child causing or permitting the life of the child to be endangered or the health of the child to be injured. Violation of this section is a class 6 felony, punishable by up to 5 years in prison. This is an unusual charge, given that it falls under the child labor prohibitions, but it is brought from time to time.
As you can see, there are a myriad of ways that Virginians can be charged with abuse or neglect of a child. These cases are exceedingly difficult, because invariably the parents or guardians love their children and the best for them. If you are facing these types of charges, do not wait... contact us right away. We are here to help!
|
|
| Continue reading "What are Virginia child abuse laws?" » |
|
| Permalink |
| | |